Unified Italy: Between Great Hopes and Great Troubles

From Cavour's Dream to Today's Nightmares: A Journey Through the History of the Italian State
September 3, 2024 by
Unified Italy: Between Great Hopes and Great Troubles
homoerectus, Alessandro Liggieri

The unification of Italy was an ambitious idea, but problems arose immediately. Discover how internal conflicts shaped modern Italy, between crises and rebirths..

The Beautiful Country That Wasn't Meant to Be (Like This)

The unification of Italy is like that birthday party everyone eagerly awaits, but that ends with someone crying in a corner and someone else storming out angrily. In 1861, Italy finally unites. Or rather, it forces itself to stay under the same roof. From that moment on, Italians had to learn to live together with their different dialects, cultures, and problems, in a sort of social experiment that didn't always go as planned. After all, what could go wrong when you put together a nation made up of states that, until recently, had looked at each other with distrust?

In 1861, the newborn Italy was a country that had to learn to walk on its own, but it had no idea where it was going. And this is just the beginning of a long and winding road filled with contrasts and compromises. Sure, there were the great hopes of figures like Cavour and Garibaldi, but also a mountain of economic, social, and political problems. It's a bit like moving into a new house and discovering that the walls are full of cracks and the heating doesn't work.

And so, the difficulties began immediately: the poor and backward South viewed the industrialized and rich North with suspicion; separatist movements arose; world wars put national unity to the test; and, of course, the perennial struggle between monarchy and republic, like a never-ending soap opera. And today, more than 160 years later, we're still here, trying to figure out whether Italy is truly united or if we're just pretending well.

From Unity to Division: When Italy Decided to Argue with Itself

The unification of Italy, as we know, was not a walk in the park. Behind the scenes, there were many, too many problems. But let's go in order and see how this grand project became a long series of family quarrels, worthy of a reality show.

1861
The Birth of an Idea (and Many Headaches)

When Victor Emmanuel II was proclaimed King of Italy in 1861, the country seemed finally united. But beneath the surface, things were far from peaceful. The North looked down on the South, and the South reciprocated with a good dose of resentment. A bit like those relatives who only tolerate each other at Christmas. The result? The so-called "Southern Question," which still sparks discussions and controversies today.

1870
Rome as the Capital: The Great Dream (or Nightmare?)  

Rome, the eternal city, finally became the capital of Italy in 1870. But not everything that glitters is gold. The capture of Rome marked the end of the papal temporal power and the beginning of a long series of clashes between the State and the Church. Think of Rome as a big party, but with two guests who can't stand each other and end up ruining the atmosphere.

1915-1918
World War I: Unity Brings Strength (or Not?)  

Italy entered World War I with the idea of completing national unity. But, as often happens, good intentions clashed with harsh reality. The war was a human and economic disaster, and Italy was more divided than ever. Social contrasts exploded, and the fragility of national unity became as evident as a crack in a freshly painted wall. 

1922
The Rise of Fascism: When Italy Decided to Get Serious (But Not Too Much) 

After the war, Italy fell into the hands of Benito Mussolini and his fascist regime. It was a period of strong authoritarianism and propaganda, in which an attempt was made to build a strong and unified national identity. But the illusion didn't last long: World War II and the fall of fascism put everything back into question. In the end, Italy found itself divided once again, this time between monarchy and republic, with the 1946 referendum marking the end of one era and the beginning of another. 

1946  
The Birth of the Republic: A New Beginning (But with Old Problems)

With the birth of the Italian Republic, Italy seemed ready to turn the page. But the past is not easily forgotten, and the contrasts between North and South, between State and Church, between different political ideologies, continued to influence the country. The 1948 Constitution tried to bring order, but the road was still long and full of obstacles. And today, as we approach 2025, Italy continues to seek a balance between its many identities.

United Italy: An (Unfinished) Dream That Still Concerns Us

Today, more than 160 years later, we can say that Italy is a country that has never really stopped. Like an old engine that keeps running, through a thousand difficulties and a bit of luck. Sure, unity has been achieved, but at what cost? And above all, is it really unity? Perhaps we're just a group of individuals sharing the same roof, but not always the same heart. But in the end, this is Italy: a country that always manages to surprise us, for better or for worse.

The journey of united Italy has been, and continues to be, a tortuous and complicated path. A bit like a soap opera that seems to never end, full of twists and dramatic moments. But despite everything, we are still here, trying to understand who we are and where we are going. Maybe, one day, we will finally find the answers we seek. Or maybe not. But one thing is certain: we never get bored.

Perché te lo consiglio

I recommend it because it highlights, with irony and sarcasm, the contradictions and human flaws that have shaped the history of united Italy. A light and entertaining way to understand a past that, whether we like it or not, belongs to us.

Perché non te lo consiglio

I don't recommend it because, if you don't like facing the reality of human flaws, this journey through the history of united Italy might be a bit too sharp for your taste. 

Unified Italy: Between Great Hopes and Great Troubles
homoerectus, Alessandro Liggieri September 3, 2024

Newsletter 

Be the first to discover all the latest news, reviews, and tips. Subscribe to the newsletter.

Share this post